MLB The Show 25 Retro Finest Program Guide
Overview
The program progresses on a 100-point reward scale. Along the way, you unlock items such as packs, XP boosts, and most importantly, five 99 OVR Retro Finest cards. These include Justin Turner at 20 points, Gary Carter at 40, Paul Goldschmidt at 60, Gary Sheffield at 80, and finally Andrew Miller at 100 points. Additional XP boosts totaling 30,000 and a Deluxe Choice Pack are also included in the reward path.
What makes this program particularly valuable is that each of these Retro Finest cards is usable immediately and fits well into both casual and competitive lineups. Players like Goldschmidt and Sheffield offer high offensive firepower, while Andrew Miller is an elite bullpen lefty with swing-and-miss potential. For gamers who actively invest in the best MLB The Show 25 Players, completing this program early helps stay ahead of the competition.
Easiest Path to 100 Points
There are three ways to earn points: Moments, PXP Missions, and Stat Missions. Completing the 10 Moments earns a total of 50 points and is an efficient way to jumpstart progress. These small challenges don't take long and can be finished in under an hour with moderate gameplay experience.
The PXP Missions are tied to the program's unlocked cards. After earning Justin Turner, Gary Carter, Paul Goldschmidt, and Gary Sheffield, you'll need to accumulate 350 Player XP (PXP) with each of them, totaling 40 points. An additional 10 points come from reaching 1,000 PXP using any Retro Finest players. These missions can be done in both single-player and multiplayer (excluding Showdown), meaning you can progress naturally by playing standard game modes.
Finally, Stat Missions award points for hitting and pitching objectives like extra-base hits with third basemen, home runs with first basemen, and strikeouts with relievers. Since these are not tied to specific players, they typically complete themselves during normal gameplay. Combining these missions with PXP progression while playing games ensures efficient multitasking.
Important Eligibility Notes
One critical detail that many players overlook is that the "Finest Series" PXP mission does not include 2025 Finest cards. Instead, it only counts Retro Finest cards or those associated with previous-year Finest campaigns. Eligible names include the five program players, plus other 99-rated options like Jose Bautista, Jimmy Rollins, Chase Headley, Jason Kipnis, Jason Varitek, and Joc Pederson. Even 98 OVR Robb Nen is eligible. If you're missing some of these players, you can purchase them using MLB 25 Stubs to speed up the grinding process.
Should You Spend MLB 25 Stubs for This Program
You don't need to spend stubs to complete the program, however, doing so can significantly speed things up, especially if you're aiming to finish before key online events. Purchasing additional Retro Finest players or lineup fillers with eligible attributes can help complete the PXP and Stat Missions faster. Strategic use of MLB 25 Stubs is often worthwhile when time is more valuable than grind hours, especially for players aiming to stay competitive early in the game cycle.
Player Performance Impact
Justin Turner offers balanced hitting and defensive versatility. Gary Carter is a dependable catcher with elite reaction and power. Paul Goldschmidt is one of the best right-handed hitters in the game with strong fielding. Gary Sheffield brings raw power and great bat speed, ideal for players who excel at timing. Andrew Miller stands out as a top-tier left-handed reliever with dominant velocity and break, making him especially valuable in Ranked.
Many players have already plugged these cards into their starting squads or as bench and bullpen options. Considering meta development and seasonal progression, these cards should remain viable long-term.
Final Thoughts
Start with the Moments to earn quick points. Then, incorporate the unlocked players into your lineup and focus on PXP accumulation in game modes such as Conquest, Mini Seasons, or Ranked. Complete stat-related missions passively while playing naturally. If you're short on time or missing key Retro Finest players, spend MLB 25 Stubs smartly to eliminate bottlenecks and maximize efficiency.
The Retro Finest Program is one of the most accessible ways to stock up on elite MLB The Show 25 Players early in the season. Whether you're competing at the highest level or casually improving your lineup, this program delivers massive value for minimal effort.
Unlock the cards, stack the XP, and take over the diamond, because this is one program you simply don't want to skip.
———— Nov-20-2025 PST ————